It's one of the most common questions we get: should I go metal or stick with shingles? We install both, so we don't have a horse in the race. Here's how they compare for homes in Northwest Arkansas.
Quick Comparison
| Architectural shingles | Standing seam metal | |
|---|---|---|
| Up-front cost | Lower | Higher |
| Typical lifespan | About 20–30 years | Often 40+ years |
| Hail | Can crack or bruise; impact-rated shingles available | May dent cosmetically, rarely leaks from hail |
| Wind | Good when properly installed | Excellent |
| Summer heat | Absorbs more heat | Many finishes reflect sunlight |
| Maintenance | Low | Very low |
| Looks | Classic, many colors | Modern farmhouse, clean lines |
Cost
Shingles cost less up front, which is why they're on most homes in NWA. Standing seam metal costs more to buy and install. But a metal roof can last twice as long, so if you're staying in your home for the long haul, the cost over time can come out closer than the sticker price suggests.
Lifespan
Architectural shingles typically last 20 to 30 years in our climate, depending on ventilation, tree cover and storms. A well-installed standing seam roof often lasts 40 years or more.
Hail and Storms
This is the big one in Northwest Arkansas. Standard shingles can crack or lose granules in a bad hail storm, which is why so many NWA roofs get replaced through insurance. Impact-rated shingles hold up better, and some insurers offer discounts for them, so ask your agent. On qualifying Malarkey shingle roofs, we can also offer a 50-year non-prorated material warranty and a 25-year workmanship warranty backed by Malarkey (installation requirements apply). Metal is very unlikely to leak from hail, but large hail can leave cosmetic dents, especially on thinner panels. Check how your policy treats cosmetic damage to metal.
Heat and Energy
Many metal roof finishes reflect sunlight, which can help keep your attic cooler in an Arkansas summer. Good attic ventilation matters with either material.
Noise
On a house with solid decking, underlayment and an insulated attic, rain on metal is usually not much louder than on shingles. The "loud tin roof" reputation comes from barns and open-framed buildings.
Which Should You Choose?
- Choose shingles if you want the lowest up-front cost, you may move in the next 10 to 15 years, or you're replacing through an insurance claim and want to match the neighborhood.
- Choose metal if you plan to stay long-term, want a roof that may never need replacing again, have a lot of trees, or love the modern farmhouse look.
- Mix them. Many homes use shingles on the main roof with standing seam metal accents over porches and bay windows.
Still deciding? We'll look at your home and give you an honest recommendation and pricing for both. Call (479) 372-3622.